Monday, April 14, 2014

Why You Are Not Getting The Expected ROI From Marketing Automation (Part 2)


You Don’t Have a Process to Automate

Overview: Let’s imagine for a moment that we are no longer talking about implementing Marketing Automation, but building a factory to manufacture hammers. Everyone knows what a hammer is, and pretty much its component parts: a hammer head and a handle. And let’s say you are in charge of automating the process of building hammers. Your instructions are, of course, 1) build hammer heads any size or shape you want and 2) build handles any size or shape you want as long as you build a bunch of them really, really fast. Right? Because how they fit together later is a problem for another time.

Well, let’s look at the way you’ve created your marketing “factory.” How much does it resemble the hammer factory described above? Are your campaigns, assets and programs all sitting in bins in a warehouse somewhere still waiting to be assembled into a finished product called Marketing Automation?

Last week we looked at the critical interdependence of the “Three Ps” People, Process and Platform. You may wonder, then, why we are beginning with the second “P” of Process, rather than People. It is a great question, and has a very straightforward answer: Process drives the requirements for People. Let’s continue with our hammer factory analogy.

To build hammers, I need to first build the two component pieces: hammer heads and hammer handles. These are two very different things made from (generally) very different materials. To correctly build a hammer, I need handles and heads built to fit together and stay together. To build wooden handles, I need a worker skilled in woodworking tools used to build the handles and to build steel heads, I need workers skilled in metallurgy, casting and forging processes. So I don’t hire highly skilled accountants or attorneys to perform these tasks.

When using the hammer factory analogy, it seems an elementary point. But going beyond theory into practice, how many people are currently in your Marketing Automation process without the key skills needed to perform their jobs at a high level? Are there copywriters building campaigns or graphic artists managing Marketing Ops because they were available resources? Do you have the correct positions defined for your organizational model and adequate job descriptions for those positions? For more information on organizational models and roles and responsibilities within those models, see my earlier series on why you are not organized for successful Marketing Automation.

We’ve talked about the component parts in your process, but we also need to address the process itself. Again, the hammer factory makes a great and simple analogy. There is an obvious order of precedence in the manufacture of a hammer, but there are also subtle sub-components of that process. Build the handle, build the head and assemble. It’s that easy, right? Ask your project managers and, if you aren’t using project managers in your automation process, consider starting that practice. Let’s examine the seemingly straightforward process of assembling a hammer head to its handle.

Consider the mortise and tenon joint and the tolerances required ensure the joint doesn’t fail after repeated, violent impacts. Are you going to slap those two pieces together with a little bubble gum and duct tape and hope it holds? Or will you require tight tolerances and a high-tension mechanical fastening system? How will you test the handle and head independently to insure they will fit? Where should the testing occur in the manufacturing cycle? At what frequency should you test? Who is authorized to test? Is testing validated, and at what frequency? Are the testing methods themselves tested?

And this is a two-piece hammer! How many independent operations and component parts comprise you marketing factory?

Understanding your Process

While it seems like a lot of process detail to build a simple hammer, that level of detail is exactly what allows for the factory to predictably manufacture high volumes of hammers with consistently high quality. Without the attention to detail, rework and scrap rates skyrocket while profits plummet.

So we’ve established detail is essential, but how much detail is enough? This checklist is a good starting point in understanding the marketing and sales processes you intend to automate. Do you currently have complete and accurate documentation for:
  • Lead process for every possible prospect input and output
  • Lead Stage system (or Demand Waterfall) with complete definitions for each stage, actions in stage and triggers
  • Defined SLAs for each Lead Stage progress
  • Defined Sales Opportunity Stages, complete with probabilities
  • Persona definitions for all of your key buyer types
  • Target market segmentation rules
  • Touch point governance rules and campaign calendars
  • Accurately catalogued asset and content libraries
 This is not an exhaustive list, but is a great starting point to determine the elements you will need to consider automating.

Notes:

Commit to your process first. If the process is right for your organization, you will find a platform that can be customized to meet your process requirements and you can hire or train the skill sets necessary to successfully manage your “Marketing Factory.”

The more detailed your planning, the more effective your MAP implementation will be. Avoid the urge to get your system up and blasting out emails. Plan and implement a long-term successful “Marketing Factory.”

If you haven’t completely implemented at least one Marketing Automation platform, you will likely need help. There are not a lot of competent and skilled consultants in the Marketing Automation space, so choose wisely.

If you do choose to hire a consultant, heed his or her advice. It is likely he or she has already seen around the corner you are currently trying to navigate. Here’s an insider’s tip: we make a lot of money fixing systems that were implemented according to a non-critical deadline rather than a process plan. For those of us old enough to remember the Fram oil filter commercials, “You can pay me now, or you can pay me later.”

People, Process and Platform – the Three P’s. In next week’s edition, we will look at the people side of the equation. It is the most difficult and most subjective element in the automation equation. But with a well-defined process as a roadmap, even the most subjective element can come into clear focus and the roadmap will help you make decisions leading to success.

Tags: Marketing Automation, Lead Management, Lead Process, Marketing Data, Sales and Marketing Process, Marketing Operations Skills, Marketing Automation Skills, Marketing Automation ROI, Marketing ROI, ROMI

Monday, April 7, 2014

Why You Are Not Getting The Expected ROI From Marketing Automation (Part 1)


Understanding The Critical Interdependence of the “Three P’s”

One of the worst question I’ve seen posted in an online forum is the seemingly benign, “Which marketing automation platform is better, Brand X or Brand Y?” It is a bit like asking, “Which color is better, blue or green?” Demand Centers are not successful based on the selection of one particular platform over another. The complex blend of the “Three P’s” – People, Process and Platform – must co-exist in a balanced symbiosis to meet your organization’s specific business requirements.

According to the Pepper B2B Marketing Automation Report 2014[i], the top three obstacles to Marketing Automation success were budget constraints, lack of skilled employees and poor contact database quality. Not mentioned: lack of platform capabilities. The simple fact is that all of the currently available MAPs have great capabilities, but each is best suited for a particular combination of the Three P’s. Your key to a successful (read: profitable) Demand Center is to understand your process and coordinate your people with the available platforms, in that order.

Understand your Process

Before embarking on the Marketing Automation journey, you absolutely must understand the marketing and sales processes you are attempting to automate. In virtually every case I have been engaged to “fix” marketing automation, the initial discovery finds a system implemented without process. It seems intuitive, but the “Automation” in Marketing Automation should beg the question, “Automate what?” If you haven’t answered that question in detail, you need to immediately address it before progressing. Key questions you need to answer are how do we:

·       Manage the Lead lifecycle?
o   Stage definitions
o   Stage triggers
o   SLAs
o   Documentation
·       Manage Campaign execution?
o   Initiation process
o   Documentation
o   Communication
o   Project Management
·       Interface with sales – both the initial Lead handoff and in final disposition of a Lead?
o   Solid MQL-SAL definition and SLA
o   Sales Enablement tools and documentation
o   Campaign Sales support

Understand Your People

Understanding your people goes beyond a list of skill sets on a resume. Although listed as a “top three obstacle” in the Pepper report above, often the personnel mismatch has to do with both the organizational model and the skill set. In a previous {Demand Gen Brief} I explored Demand Center Organization models and the required skill sets (the four-part series begins here).

The first part of your people assessment is to inventory the existing skill sets among your current staff. The Second is to understand the Demand Center organization model you are implementing. You can reference my four-part {Demand Gen Brief} series for help there. Finally, you can perform a gap analysis between your current skills inventory and those necessary to effectively deploy your Demand Center model.

Understand Your Platform (Requirements)

Hopefully, you have not yet made that decision. If you have already implemented a MAP, you should probably spend more time working on the People and Process parts of the equation before making any decisions on how to align your MAP to those elements.

Notice the “(Requirements)” added to the section title above. Too often, MAP purchase decisions are made based on flashy demonstrations and feature comparisons. They should be made based on a set of requirements generated as a result of studying your processes and people (skills sets and organization model requirements). To make the comparison simpler, let’s place it in another context, a vehicle purchase.

If you need a vehicle and your requirement is one that will efficiently get you to the beach (we might as well make it a fun analogy). If you require taking yourself, your significant other, two towels and a picnic basket, a Fiat 500 would be a fun and economical choice. If your beach excursion requires towing a 32-foot fishing boat, perhaps the Fiat isn’t the best choice. Although the analogy is simple, you will want to use a similar approach in defining your MAP requirements.

Notes:

Although we can’t possibly explore every possible combination of requirements here, there are some general principles that apply. These illustrate the interdependence of the Three P’s.

More complex your process requirements = Less “friendly” the user interface.
You will need a team of platform experts to drive your platform.
People
--> Platform

More distributed campaign execution team = More robust communications requirements.
You will need structured communications between distributed departments to prevent oversaturation and confusing messaging.
People
--> Process

More centralized Demand Center = More robust programmatic processing abilities.
Centralized execution requires robust programming to extract value from repetitive processes.
Process
--> Platform

Organizationally distributed content and campaign execution = simpler user interface.
Your user base will be less technical, requiring ease of use over power and flexibility.
Platform --> People

People, Process and Platform – the Three P’s. In next week’s edition, we will take a deeper look into Process, and why so many organizations don’t adequately understand the processes they are trying to automate.


[i] 2014 Marketing Automation Survey, Pepperglobal.com, 2 North LaSalle Street, Chicago, IL 60602